Resisting the “One-Way Train”: Adapting to Parkinson’s Without Surrender

“You keep moving until something stops you.” — Sue Goldie

Sue Goldie is

  • A Harvard professor.
  • The director of a research center and a teaching center at the school.
  • A recipient of a MacArthur Foundation Genius Grant for “applying the tools of decision science to evaluate the clinical benefits, public health impact, and cost-effectiveness of alternative preventive and treatment interventions for viruses that are major public health problems.”
  • A triathelete — something she took up in her late fifties.

I’m guessing she’s smarter than most of us, more disciplined than most, and has connections we can only dream of.

Parkinson’s doesn’t care about any of that.

According to a powerful piece by John Branch in the New York Times, Sue Goldie first noticed symptoms and received her diagnosis in 2021.

Since that diagnosis, Parkinson’s has put her through her own unique version of the same challenges the rest of us face.

A constantly changing potpourri of symptoms — some visible, some not. Stress, which can make the symptoms worse, which can cause more stress. Agonizing questions about who to tell, and when. Fear of professional repercussions when her employer and colleagues find out. And the realization that the disease is, as she put it, a “one-way train.”

The article is sometimes uplifting, sometimes depressing. In spite of all of her intelligence and resources, the disease is, as she put it, a “one-way train.”

But there are useful lessons scattered throughout the story.

There’s no one right answer to the question of who to tell, and when. I told my employer and co-workers within a couple of weeks of diagnosis. Goldie held off for four years, worried about the impact the news would have on her reputation and professional opportunities.

The Michael J. Fox Foundation recently released a podcast episode on navigating the workplace with Parkinson’s. It’s worth a listen. One piece of advice stuck with me — consult an employment lawyer to get a handle on what your rights are before telling your employer.

Adapt your approach when necessary. She now “she draws and writes less than she used to during her lectures and videos, relying instead on a cache of prewritten, predrawn cutouts that she can move around in front of her.”

Change the equipment. We are lucky to live in a world where helpful tools abound. I’m a big fan of the left-handed mouse and voice-to-text typing. For Goldie: “Pink tape on her hands to provide visual clues of her swim stroke. Special gear shifters and a long tube rigged as a straw on her bike’s water bottle because she no longer has the dexterity and balance to take a hand off the handlebars.”

It’s okay to change your goals. Initially, Goldie insisted on completing full Ironman triathalons. Over time, she and her coaches conclude that a race that can take up to 17 hours is too risky, given her physical and medication challenges. So she switches to “half Ironman” competitions.

Exercise is beneficial, but there are limits.* Goldie trains for and competes in triathalons — a grueling sport for any age, but perhaps especially so for person in her 60’s with Parkinson’s. Branch says Goldie believes that this is benefiting her:

It’s difficult, if not impossible, to measure the effect of her exercise against the silent creep of Parkinson’s. There are so many variables, and she is just one person. But she has little doubt that she would be much worse off without triathlon.

But her symptoms are getting worse, and she’s been injured several times.

Overtraining can cause serious health problems for any athlete. And Parkinson’s researchers have found that too much exercise “can lead to weight loss, fatigue, and an increase in off episodes,  periods when symptoms return between treatment doses.

So this passage from the Times piece is troubling:

Sue is struggling to manage wild dopamine swings with medications and dosages. She is recovering from a string of serious injuries she endured in 2023 from falls and collisions — a broken clavicle, a broken rib, an orbital fracture from smashing into a two-by-four sticking out of a truck bed during a training run. Most of them, she thinks, would not have happened without Parkinson’s.

Goldie’s doctors don’t appear in the article; we don’t get any sense of what they think. I hope the risks of overtraining are at least an occasional topic of conversation within her care team.

It’s our game, but Parkinson’s writes the rules — and can change them without notice at any time. Goldie is often struggling behind closed doors to perform tasks that once were simple and natural for her. Her students and many of her colleagues only see the final performance, and are unaware of the sweat and strain necessary to make the performance happen.

Like many of us, Sue Goldie fights each day to maintain the things that brings meaning to her life and career — and to make it look easy. As she tells John Branch, “You have no idea how hard it is to trick you into thinking I’m OK.”

Keep moving.

*Special thanks to Sharon Krischer, writer of the Twitchy Woman blog, whose post got me thinking about this issue.

Bonus for Those Who Read to the Bottom

A very enthusiastic rendition of “If You Knew Susie.”

.

Reggae Pink Floyd, by Alpha Blondy.

.

I heard the Clash’s rendition of “Police on My Back” at the gym the other day (thanks, Dave!). Here’s the original by The Equals, featuring a very young Eddy Grant.

11 responses to “Resisting the “One-Way Train”: Adapting to Parkinson’s Without Surrender”

  1. pdxknitterati Avatar

    Everything in moderation. I remember when you added spinning to your exercise routine, and your tremor increased. Your doctor felt you were metabolizing your meds more quickly due to exercise, and adjusted your dosage. The point is that you had that conversation, and worked it out.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. shakinstreet.com Avatar

      Hard to tell what conversations she’s had with her medical team — they didn’t participate (on the record, anyway) in the article. But I agree with you that it’s an important conversation to have, and one that should be continuous as conditions change.

      Like

  2. catjollyfbfca93c2d Avatar
    catjollyfbfca93c2d

    PD certainly is a game changer isn’t it, and as it progresses, it becomes more and more difficult to ignore. Thank you for sharing this. I look forward to reading her story.

    Like

    1. shakinstreet.com Avatar

      The story is well worth the read. It can be read as an uplifting story of a courageous woman fighting a tough battle. It can also be read as the story of a person whose insistence on extreme exercise is causing her to self-destruct.

      I’ve had offline conversations with readers on both sides of that question, and can’t quite decide how I feel about it.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. JB358PWP Avatar
        JB358PWP

        I think we all are experiencing PD on our own individual level, and dealing with it in our own way. Having said that, you would hope she’s working with her doctor, but she also might just be in a bit of denial. I was also diagnosed in 2021, with only an internal tremor, stiff right hand, and arm that didn’t straighten all the way. Until this past year, I really didn’t experience any other symptoms. I’d say I was a bit in denial now that the disease has progressed with a flourish.

        Like

  3. jchrisanthony Avatar

    Very informative. I read the New York Times piece this morning. I watched the Still movie about MJF last night. Between the two, they provide a window into our future. Thanks for posting this.

    Like

    1. shakinstreet.com Avatar

      Haven’t watched the Michael J. Fox movie yet — I suspect because it shows a future I’m reluctant to face.

      Like

  4. mentalitycheerfullya4b3f4e660 Avatar
    mentalitycheerfullya4b3f4e660

    i read the NYT article and it made me cry. But it also made me quite sad…..she appeared to be so desperate. Those of us with PD at some point need to come to terms with the disease that some adjustment/changes need to be applied to our lives. For me, at this point, these are minor changes but allow for a very active, fulfilling life. Coming to terms with this harsh reality can provide some peace and joy, even if its not long lasting.

    Like

    1. shakinstreet.com Avatar

      There’s probably a line between giving this a legitimate fight and being desperate… and between gracefully accepting/adjusting to the inevitable and giving up. Based on the description of the writer, she might be on the “desperate” side of the line — but the line’s blurry, and it moves.

      Like

      1. JB358PWP Avatar
        JB358PWP

        I wonder if there isn’t a little desperation in all of us. We research and Google and grab onto the latest supplement hoping it’s going to be the magic pill.

        Like

  5. jc3106850 Avatar
    jc3106850

    My Parkinson’s disease began relatively early, at the age of 58, and the initial diagnosis was traumatic for me. Over time, I was introduced to many pharmaceutical treatments, which offered little relief, and as the years passed, my symptoms continued to worsen. I was close to giving up when I learned about EarthCure Herbal Clinic and their herbal treatments through their website, “w w w. earthcureherbalclinic. com”. After using their supplements for a few months, I noticed a drastic improvement, my symptoms gradually disappeared. Eventually, I realized that I had completely recovered. I later went for another medical examination and diagnosis, which confirmed that I no longer had Parkinson’s disease. I am deeply grateful to EarthCure Herbal Clinic for their support, and I wholeheartedly recommend them.

    Like

Leave a reply to shakinstreet.com Cancel reply

I’m Phil Bernstein

I was diagnosed with Parkinson’s Disease on May 25, 2023. At the time, I was only vaguely aware of Parkinson’s — primarily from articles in People about Michael J. Fox. And I didn’t know anyone with the disease.

Now, I know a lot more about the illness, and I’ve joined the Parkinson’s community in my hometown of Portland, Oregon.

I’ve found that writing helps me think through challenges, and this illness definitely qualifies as a challenge. I’ve started Shakin’ Street to help me think through the various obstacles, tools, and resources that a newly-diagnosed Parkinson’s patient encounters along the way.

I hope some of these posts help you address and tackle your own challenges.

Let’s connect